Sam here again.Is new remastered vinyl fake vinyl?

Many, many variables in making a quality sounding LP.
My reissue of Tommy sounds very good, but I will agree that the original has a better sound quality.  However, my original copy is way too noisy and has just seen it's better day.  I will settle for a littles less analogue SQ but with the absence of noise.  I can't find a clean original copy that will satisfy me (NM,M-). 
I tried the remastered version of Led Zeppelin, Houses of the Holy, and sent it back.  My original copy (I have had since it was first released) does have some surface noise, and maybe the quality of the vinyl was not the best, but certainly has more of an analogue sound.  I'll play that one.
However, the recent reissue of Dire Straits on "audiophile" quality vinyl and at 45 RPM is light-years beyond my original copy (and yes, I have had that too, since it was first released).  It was remastered to perfection using the original master tapes, by the best in the business, and was plated/pressed to perfection on superior grade vinyl.  It's one of the best sounding LPs I own.
Examples abound and I could go on.  But, you should be able to get the idea from those cited above.  Again, there are many variables in making a quality sounding LP.  Given the same album, I still prefer playing from my LP collection verses any digital source material.

I agree with millercarbon, as if you like the sound of analog or LP'S, why would you not just buy from say discogs, ebay, or a host of other sites as well as local used record stores? I've been able to find almost anything I wanted by all the above options and most of the time the record Is of decent or better quality. There are just way to many options out there for you to say that this is what is holding you back from getting a turntable. 

+1 to au_lait and mammothguy.  Too many plausible explanations for the differences than a conspiracy theory, IMHO.

If you like records, it's work, albeit the best kind of work! Every record you want IS possible to attain, at the price YOU want, if you are patient. I’ve spent half my life in the bins at record shops, the music IS there you just have to be diligent. Better yet, go to the record fairs, but beware of sharks. Reissues rarely guarantee better quality unless the original was dogshit to begin with, or you initially bought a crap Greek, Czech, Mexican, etc pressing.