Your thoughts on upgrading Feickert protractor


There's too much slack in the Pin hole that hovers over the center arm pivot. There should be a longer sleeve there of tighter tolerances to allow for a more accurate measure of S2P.

Your thoughts.
128x128slaw
@wlutke ,

I'm actually enjoying my VPI now that I found and fixed most of the manufacturing defects.

Peace
Just use trammel points. Dead accurate, dirt cheap. You can draw big circles with them also for when you want to play twister.
Are you serious? chakster protractor CAN’T be improved. It is already the best (grin).

Exactly, i sill hope to meet a super human being who can detect by ears a tiny difference in alignment within a few microns.

seriously, magnifying glass and lighting is what i'd like to add for improvement
Agree that instructions printed on the template itself, on the "old" Feickert protractor, are very vague. In fact, you sort of have to know what to do a priori in order to understand the instructions. For example, you set up the protractor based on the range of the expected P2S (where S = Spindle) distance, and then you set the stylus on an arc calibrated based on P2S, when in fact you are setting pivot to stylus distance, in that first step. But, at least with my original version Feickert, Steps 1, 2 AND 3 ought to be spot on, as I think it was Lutke said. If step 3 is not spot on, there was a small error in step 1 or 2. A small error in the first two steps is magnified in step 3, which is why step 3 is offered. This, my friends, is why I never bother with Step 3; I don’t give a hoot about a small error.
I agree with Chakster on the need for magnification and a high intensity light, if you wanna get crazy with the Feickert or most other protractors.  That is exactly what is offered for the premium price you have to pay to get the SMARTractor, which is otherwise based on the Dennesen, which is also the basis for the Feickert.  In addition, the Smartie gives you perfect accommodation for any one of three spindle diameters.  (I own a UNItractor, the precursor to the Smartie.)