2. misc-audio
  3. 158145-3130

Why Don't More People Into Music Reproduction At Home Play Around With Musical Instruments

 In the pursuit of music reproduction in the home it is my firm belief that you must listen to live music every now & again so that you know & understand how real music,with real instruments,in real physical spaces sounds...
 With that as a foundation I used in judging equipment's "voice" I also believe that playing around with a musical instrument is an excellent way to gain first hand experience with musical sound...EVERY person that reads this can learn a few musical notes,on ANY musical instrument on the planet..For instance I play around with electric guitar.NO I can NOT play,but I can play the notes EFG,on first string & BCD on the second string...Now  I know those few notes & easily recognize them in any song..I am just this coming week going to start playing around with an electric keyboard....So I wonder,why don't more audiophiles simply play around with real instruments as part of their pursuit of honest reproduction in the home?Surely the education in reality is worth the $100.00 it takes to get an entry level guitar,keyboard,horn etc...
freediver
richopp
760 posts
 
No talent from whomever hands out the musical talent gene--and either you have it or you do not, period.  I played several instruments starting in about 2nd grade, but was never that good at any of them. 

Fast forward to college, and guitar and drums became my choices and I played in several bands, but was the only "non-musician" in any of them.

Forward again to the early 1970's when I opened my shop.  What a revelation is was to stumble through a song myself and and then listen to a reproduced version.  Taught me that box speakers of the day, while fine, were not capable of accurately reproducing the sounds that I played on the actual instruments, even at a basically beginner level.  Closest to real were speakers from Magnepan, and they have improved quite a bit since the early 1970's.

That's what messing with instruments did for me, and I still have a few around that I mess with now that I am retired.  It is relaxing and enjoyable, but of course no one else has to listen!

Cheers!
twoleftears's avatar
twoleftears
5,320 posts
 

I started learning clarinet around age 11.  I played for 20 years or so.  At 14 I also took up alto sax, and later tenor.  I got quite good on the clarinet, good enough to know exactly how much daily practice it would take to get significantly better. Hours and hours every day.  As it was clear that I was never going to make a living doing that, that's when I had to throttle back, and listening really took over.

But there is nothing like sitting in the middle of a full-scale orchestra when it's playing at full tilt.  Not necessarily the perspective you want from your audio system, but unique and energizing nonetheless.

jmforge
16 posts
 
Musical instruments? Bah!!They are fraught with imperfections. As a matter of fact, some of these crazy people who like “vintage” electric guitars and amplifiers Actually like them for their glaring sonic imperfections. I hesitate to mention this, but some of them even not only like distortion, but seek ways to increase it and enhance it. Oh the humanity!
guidocorona
4,298 posts
 

All, not all categories of musical instruments require capital investments comparable to high end audio equipment.

　

European made 1st tier professional level High brass horns can be had for well under $4K. See for example the rather spectacular Adams trumpets, flugelhorns, and cornets from Dutch master designer and manufacturer Miel Adams. Even low brass euphoniums are typically below $10K.... Only tubas tend to rest in the double-digit range:

　

https://www.austincustombrass.biz/brands/Adams.html

　

Quality 2nd tier horns are even more affordable. See the wide range of low and high brass offerings from Wessex Tuba:

　

https://wessex-tubas.com/

　

Yes, while in a distance past I studied classical piano and voice, and later played flute, I have more recently been dabbling with brass... My "true love" being the euphonium.

　

One interesting characteristics of brass instruments is that they require a modicum of finger agility only with one hand. This is usually the right hand, although left-handed horns are also available from several manufacturers.

　

Admittedly, playing any musical instrument with a modicum of success is, well.... Work :) On the other hand, the skill does not necessarily require the ability of reading musical scores.

　

So, friend @Noble100 (Tim), you being able to enjoying playing a horn is not at all out of the question... Send me a PM if you would like to chat about it... The short Bb cornet, flugel horn, and euphonium might work particularly well for you.

　

Saluti, Guido


isochronism
2,893 posts
 
(a) Fender Tweed Champ amp with maxed-out volume (12) started the whole rock guitar sound. It is reputed that Eric Clapton recorded Layla with one as his studio amp. "... some of these crazy people..." are you insinuating someone like wolf Garcia be considered as crazy?? (I have an old tweed champ, also) and I'm far from crazy.
More to discover