VPI HW-19 or VPI Traveler

You haven't given a lot of information about the HW-19, including the platter that's on it.   You say it is in new condition.  The only thing that really matters is the bearing.  It needs to be inspected.  Given the age of the unit, it is likely to need a new ball and thrust plate to be in "new condition."

If it is really in new condition it's the one I would buy.  If its price + restoring the bearing to new condition is less (or maybe even a bit more)  than the new Traveler it would be my choice.

Just one person's opinion.

Well that's a good point. Nothing has been done to the bearing. It has been well taken care of though based on pics and description. 

Admittedly I am new in the VPI world. Im coming from a Technics SL-1700 MK2. Assuming I'll have to service the HW-19 does it take it out of contention? Im will to service it if needed as long as the cost to do so still makes sense. Any idea what replacing the bearings might cost? I appreciate the help so far

Ask them if they ever lubed the motor and platter bearings.      One nice aspect: if you shop around, there are numerous HW-19 upgrades that can be performed at your leisure ie: SDS, SAMA, Scout platter and inverted bearing, etc).        If you have trouble getting in touch with VPI, these guys are knowledgeable regarding their parts prices and availability:     https://elusivedisc.com/search?search_query=vpi