Cantilever, not stylus!
AT-ART9XI Cartridge - Reduced Compliance
Hi folks, I'm leaning toward the AT-ART9 cartridge for my SME V. The new version - the ART9XI - has a thicker solid boron stylus (was .26mm, now .28mm) and slightly lower compliance (was 18, now 15 x10-6).
The newer version costs $300 more ($1,300 v. $1,000). I'm inclined to buy the old one. Any opinions? (Please keep in mind I bought my SME V 30 years ago when it was $2k even.) Thanks in advance!
The newer version costs $300 more ($1,300 v. $1,000). I'm inclined to buy the old one. Any opinions? (Please keep in mind I bought my SME V 30 years ago when it was $2k even.) Thanks in advance!
- ...
- 37 posts total
The XI will sound less warm, more transparent and neutral. Even in this video you can hear the difference. I owned the 9 for a few years and loved it. works best with a low mass arm e.g. 9 grams or so. - your tonearm will work better with the XI. as long as the XI keeps the squeaky clean colorful refinement of the '9, i could easily live with a more neutral sound. https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=4&v=1QA1jw5Pj7Y&feature=emb_logo |
avanti, thanks very much for the excellent A/B/C comparison video by Lp Gear. As much as I've been reading about various cartridges, I was unaware of these videos - let alone one that gives us the three ART9 models. Very helpful. The SME V's stated effective mass is 10/11, just barely into mid mass range. Cart/arm resonance with the ART9XI is in the high 9's, a more comforting number than the ART9's high 8's. Good point about the combo! noromance, cantilever is correct; I parroted "stylus" from the Lp Gear site. My bad. |
One of those two new versions, probably the lowest output one, seems to be an update (or an up-cost) of the ART7, in disguise. I am very fond of the ART7. I am not into or able to split hairs about minute differences among very similar cartridges, because there are so many uncontrolled variables involved in setting up a cartridge, starting with the tonearm and headshell and ending with the set-up procedure and how reproducibly it is done, any one of which could account for the nuances you do or don't hear. |
- 37 posts total