2. speakers
  3. 159790-2137

Turned Off My Subwoofer ... And My Speakers Sound Great

I’ve had a pair of JA Pulsars (non-Graphene) for a couple of years now, and have been using them with a subwoofer. Today, I noticed that my Pulsars sounded very different. There was an expansion of soundstaging, the bass was more articulate and robust (i.e., it had more weight to it), and the highs really sparkled.

This was somewhat different from the sound to which I had become accustomed, so I looked on the panel and discovered that the sub had been turned off. Apparently, my wife had been dusting around my listening room and had accidentally hit the off switch.

I am kind of befuddled by this because I thought use of the subwoofer was supposed to achieve those sonically pleasing effects. Apparently not in my case. Have any ’Goners had this happen? I’m really happy with the "new" sound sans subwoofer, but continue to wonder why that is. I mean by all objective measures, the sub should improve the sound, not detract from it. I just don’t get it.
rlb61
rlb61 OP
789 posts
 
FWIW, Jeff Joseph (who personally set up the Pulsars in my room) told me he thinks that because of the small room size, the subwoofer likely overloaded the room with bass. He thinks also that integrating a sub in such a small space is quite challenging. I tend to agree. In any event, this entire process, caused accidentally, has been quite a revelation. I guess everything happens for a reason.
tomic601's avatar
tomic601
12,928 posts
 
Well then, there’s always the Pulsar 2 Graphene....
three_easy_payments's avatar
three_easy_payments
2,097 posts
 
Careful @rlb61   you're going to disrupt MC's one-size fits all narrative.  He really doesn't need to post here....he simply needs to have a FAQ page with his list of audio rules (including non-negotiable brand requirements) that everyone is required to follow.

@millercarbon ... trust me, it’s way too tight for a DBA in my room. As I read the comments here and think about what has happened, I’ve concluded that a subwoofer is not necessary in every application where a 2 way speaker is used. That was a mistake on my part.
grey9hound
1,112 posts
 
If you like your sub turned off you had the wrong sub,
Not necessarily true. It is most likely out of phase or you have room nodes .
The only room Correction that I have found that gets this Exactly right is Is "RoomPerfect" by Steinway Lyngdorf . It is glorious.
I have tried ARC, Audyssey, YPAO and MCACC. None come close to Lyngdorf. It is head and shoulders above the rest.

rlb61 OP
789 posts
 
@tomic601  I've heard both versions of the Pulsars in different rooms with different systems. I'm convinced that the Graphene 2 provides an incremental upgrade over the non-Graphene model. On a percentage basis, I'd say it's about a 3% improvement, in which case the law of diminishing returns applies for me.  
More to discover