Anyone listen to Zu Audio's Definition Mk3?

I'm really not sure why this amp-Zu Def 4s synergy argument is generating quite so much heat. It's great to see such heartfelt opinions, but there must be a fair amount of latitude in choosing the amp that works best with the Def 4s in any given room.
I have to say that moving away from belt drive tt/pivoted arm, to direct rim drive/linear tracking means I'll never go back, but I'd never say my way would suit everyone. Similarly, those who've progressed from SS to tubes, or vice versa surely wouldn't claim their way was the only way?
Surely a spkr with as much flexibility in being driven (100dB+ eff) is really going to allow a whole extra range of tube amps esp. SETs to work with it, and similarly it's lack of crossover surely will get the best out of a range of SS choices.
It so happens in my case I stumbled across a really holistic tube pre/SS pow combination in the Hovland HP200/Radia, and I can't wait to hear how it struts it's stuff with the Def 4s. It would seriously have to be found wanting for me to consider another round of costly upgrading.
Really happy with new tt/arm, have got ideas for upgrading current carts/phono, cd great, amps fine, new speakers...looking fwd!

Overall, Zu makes a line of speakers that is amp-friendly to a wider range of electronics than any speaker brand I can think of. 101db/w/m efficiency that can also handle high power tube or solid state amps without distress. Relatively flat impedance curves, controlled floor & ceiling effects in Omen Def and Definition, check. Omen, the older Druid and Presence are/were ambidextrous about solid state or tube suitability. Superfly, the upcoming Coax and Definition "work" with anything but are considerably more exclusive about amplifier compatibility to sound musically outstanding (though this isn't strictly a cost issue, as the synergy between Quad II & II-Forty and Zu demonstrates). They are less forgiving of compromises in solid state designs than same in tube amplifiers, but overall there is a much narrower range of optimum amps for Superfly, Definition and the upcoming Coax. Still, people who don't like or don't want a tube amp have a half dozen compatible (and exceptional) solid state brands that make music with Zu. And sure, I'll put ASR among them. I think you can get much further with the right tube amplifiers but that doesn't really matter unless you're asking for direction. For whatever reason a Zu owner wants or prefers solid state amplification, they should have it. The issue here is that these forums become a permanent record of advocacy on the web.

Zu Definitions solve so many problems in music presentation that the amplifier just has to be good to put you in the realm of convincing hifi. The reason these amplifier topics become controversial is because the speaker is so good that once you hear it with even reasonable associated gear, the human brain (being a hungry beast) gets focused on extracting the nth degree of performance. And there's another thing: Zu upends the traditional weight in hifi given to the source. The amp/Zu interface becomes -- after the speaker itself -- the single most influential element in your system's sound. In a Zu system, much more rides on the amp selection than in systems built around most other speakers. Hence the heat the topic generates.

Phil

Phil,
I`m curious would a 2 watt 45 amp or say a 6EM7 tube amp drive your Def IV speakers? or perhaps a 2A3 amp? I ask because 100 db is really high sensitivity and a Xoverless design is an easy load(at least in theory).

I see posts by other gon members who use these types of amps to effectively drive Fostex single driver speakers(usally 97 db ) as well as Lowther based speakers. These listeners seem happy with the results within reasonable limits.Your 845 tube amp seems like plenty of surplus power for a true 100 db speaker.
Regards,

Charles,

I have this "2 watts" discussion all the time.

Look, it certainly works and 45 amps like the Yamamoto are revered by some who gravitate to flea power triodes. The tonal realism, immediacy and beauty can be arresting -- for awhile. I don't recommend this route however. The reason is that even at 101db/w/m efficiency, the dynamic limits of such a small amp are still quite noticed, even in a modest room, and that constant sense of grazing the ceiling -- or banging your head right through it -- is distracting. I find the 45 adherents forced to listen within dynamic limits that are excessively restrictive.

These 2w amps aren't cheap either. So instead, a well-executed 300B amp ala Audion Silver Night or Golden Nights can deliver all the tone, nuance and subtlety, but with acceptable dynamics. I consider a 300B's 7-8 w or perhaps a PX-25's 6-7w the practical lower limit for pairing Zu to an SET amp with true-tone attributes and acceptable dynamic range.

Better yet is a well-executed 845, but we've already discussed that.

Gerritt at Zu (the man you generally get when you dial them up) loves the Yamomoto 45 amp on his speakers, and recommends it unequivocably. I think if you are the kind of audiophile who has a small inventory of high quality amps in rotation, it's worth having a 45 like the Yamo or something similar among them. You'll love it some of the time. But if you have one amp only, I advise against 2w amps for Zu, as being too dynamically limited for general satisfaction. On balance for me, 2w amps give up too much in dynamic ease and headroom to gain what's lovely about them. Others may disagree.

There is one interesting way to justify it however. Are you a headphones listener? EddieCurrent has a sub-$3000 2a3 headphone amp that also has speaker outputs. Into speakers it outputs 3w/ch. Justify it for headphones and tap that flea power for speakers when you feel the urge to switch a few cables.

Phil

Phil,
Thanks for your reply. Like I mentioned I asked out of pure curiosity. My 8 watt 300b works well with my 94 db speaker with multiple genres of music. So I thought 2 watts with a 100 db speaker would roughly be equal. I experience no sense of 'bumping' against a dynamic ceiling. Of course all flea powered amps(5 watts or less) are`nt created equal so there`s likely some range of varying sucess among them.
Thanks,