I have a tube preamp and amp that works well with my speakers. They have good tubes.
I have a good integrated solid state amp that works well with my speakers.
Here’s the comparison I did. Keeping the DAC and the source the same:
(a) SS-Tube. When I run the solid state integrated as a preamp only through the tube amp, it sounds ok.
(b) Tube-SS. When I run the tube preamp through the integrated’s amp section only it sounds much better.
So, in my particular setup (only!) I can conclude that the preamp makes the bigger difference.
My tube and solid state are at similar price points. I realize that my tastes, impedance matching, etc. could be factors here, but I do hear a clear difference. Preamp more important in my setup.