There is so much more to that than just the driver size...
Longer time ago I had a smaller room, smth like 8’4 by 14’, 10’4 ceiling, old apartment building. It could be filled by bookshelves with 6” drivers. Floorstanders with 10” were just too much. I sold the floorstanders to a friend, in his approx 16’ by 17’ by 9’6 from they are much better (even when poorly placed).
my current room is 21’ by 23’, 8’4 ceiling with 7’ by 10’ opening to above + two other openings effectively increasing the volume by some 50%. Used Lowther Fidelios for a time, poor bass with solid state, adequate with 300B SET. That’s 8” + folded rear horn.
Acquired ancient yet immaculate MBL 101c. Base drivers is approx. 9” diameter, probably 13” tall, radially pulsating elongated aluminium ellipsoid. Deepest bass was lacking, but the room was filled so much better than with Lowthers. MBLs need ML 23 to come alive, less power and control is not for them. Wanted cleaner bass, got Gradient 1.5 Helsinki. Got the clean bass (not very much of it though). Overall, almost ‘near field’ listening - truly amazing in the sweet spot, adequate background music in the whole room, yet no freedom of movement like with the MBLs.
Decided to build dipole subs “a la Celestion 6000”, got some BMS 18N862 drivers. Connected them straight to power amp (naked drivers on the floor). 18” drivers, so no heights, on the floor, so terrible early reflections - yet smth. very immediate, coherent, and “right”. Added BSS 966, lifted lows (dipole correction) and heights. Not perfect, but good enough to make me wonder why people insist on boxes, and am I really in a hurry to complete the project as intended. And I have only connected one pair of those BMS, with two per side there will be no shortage of sufficiently deep, yet clean and dry bass. But BMSs do not fill the room. I absolutely need to add omnidirectional speakers from 200 Hz (I.e., above room modes).
I will have two options for omnidirectional, MBLs and German Physiks DDD drivers. When I make ‘enclosures’ for DDDs, I will see if size matters (MBLs have much larger total radiating surface).
Longer time ago I had a smaller room, smth like 8’4 by 14’, 10’4 ceiling, old apartment building. It could be filled by bookshelves with 6” drivers. Floorstanders with 10” were just too much. I sold the floorstanders to a friend, in his approx 16’ by 17’ by 9’6 from they are much better (even when poorly placed).
my current room is 21’ by 23’, 8’4 ceiling with 7’ by 10’ opening to above + two other openings effectively increasing the volume by some 50%. Used Lowther Fidelios for a time, poor bass with solid state, adequate with 300B SET. That’s 8” + folded rear horn.
Acquired ancient yet immaculate MBL 101c. Base drivers is approx. 9” diameter, probably 13” tall, radially pulsating elongated aluminium ellipsoid. Deepest bass was lacking, but the room was filled so much better than with Lowthers. MBLs need ML 23 to come alive, less power and control is not for them. Wanted cleaner bass, got Gradient 1.5 Helsinki. Got the clean bass (not very much of it though). Overall, almost ‘near field’ listening - truly amazing in the sweet spot, adequate background music in the whole room, yet no freedom of movement like with the MBLs.
Decided to build dipole subs “a la Celestion 6000”, got some BMS 18N862 drivers. Connected them straight to power amp (naked drivers on the floor). 18” drivers, so no heights, on the floor, so terrible early reflections - yet smth. very immediate, coherent, and “right”. Added BSS 966, lifted lows (dipole correction) and heights. Not perfect, but good enough to make me wonder why people insist on boxes, and am I really in a hurry to complete the project as intended. And I have only connected one pair of those BMS, with two per side there will be no shortage of sufficiently deep, yet clean and dry bass. But BMSs do not fill the room. I absolutely need to add omnidirectional speakers from 200 Hz (I.e., above room modes).
I will have two options for omnidirectional, MBLs and German Physiks DDD drivers. When I make ‘enclosures’ for DDDs, I will see if size matters (MBLs have much larger total radiating surface).