Tweeter/Mid minimum amp power rating for magnepan 20.1 in active setup?

unfortunately, I can't seem to find any graphs for impedance but I know they don't drop below 4 ohms. I think I will need to home demo a few amps and see how it goes.

I'm using an external active crossover.

Thank you, psilonaught.

Eyeballing Stereophile’s impedance curve of the MG-20, it looks like 4 ohms nominal (for the mid/tweet section) with a ballpark 12-ohm peak a little south of 2 kHz. That’s a 3-to-1 peak; not horrendous, but not insignificant within the context of tube amps. And assuming the 20.1’s impedance curve is similar, and that it was designed with constant-voltage (solid state) amps in mind, imo that impedance peak is worth paying attention to.

You see, a solid state amp will deliver 1/3 as much wattage into that 12-ohm peak as what it delivers into 4-ohm portions of the impedance curve. The designer presumably took that into account when he "voiced" the speakers.

Tube amps tend to deliver much closer to the same wattage into that 12-ohm peak as into the 4-ohm-nominal rest of the spectrum. So a tube amp may result in a frequency response emphasis in that region, because there the speaker will be getting more wattage than the designer anticipated. Imo one solution is to make the impedance curve more tube-amp-friendly.

EVERY TIME I have been able to thoroughly investigate someone trying a specialty tube amp and not liking it, I have found a plausible explanation in the loudspeaker’s impedance curve. I’m NOT saying "don’t try it" - quite the contrary; Maggies + tubes can equal MAGIC - but I suggest that you work with someone who is at least aware of the issue.

(The 3.6 was a particularly tube-friendly Maggie. It had a relatively small and narrow impedance peak at about 1.5 kHz, which also happened to be where it had a frequency-response DIP with a solid state amp, so the synergy with tubes was really good.)

Best of luck to you.

Duke

Reference: http://www.atma-sphere.com/en/resources-paradigms-in-amplifier-design.html

Duke has it right. I'm 50% with tube amps on Maggies, some work some don't. Magnepan has never demoed with tube amps, that might tell you something.

thanks guys.

I think I need to stick to something with 100w minumum for the top end, therefore. Something audio research is probably a good idea I guess.

Not sure how much this would help with your speakers but it might give a general idea.
https://www.crownaudio.com/en/tools/calculators