2. digital
  3. 164561-70778

CD player reliability.... good and bad.

Since the mid late 80’s I have gone through probably 15 + CD players, some lasted me many many years, some were non working out of box, some lasted a week, some months, and as said some lasted years.
Is the shipping process causing some jolting of the unit, and innards get jolted and the tray or a small piece gets damaged? Or just the way they are made?

We take great care of our CD players, dust cover when not in use, don’t drop them, hit them, shake them.....yet they just stop working or things go bad, skipping, display goes out prematurely, tray rubs on something, or any number of issues...!! ??

BUT,....my cheap pickup truck CD player still works after 13+ years , dust, bumps, filth, exploding pops, lots of dust in my truck from my profession, dash, floor, everywhere, years of dust, caked all over, yet I put in a cd, and the darn thing still works.

But , recently it has started to act up, it plays everything I put in it, but sometimes won’t eject,...


anyway, why is it most CD players have a reliability problem. NOT all of them, but there seems to be a %10-15 of new players that arrive in non-working, or only last a short time.

Any thoughts......
128x128arcticdeth
digsmithd
913 posts
 
Just...got my simaudio 5.3 back from them after this thing sitting in the closet for at least 6+ years...I had some communication issues with them and was’nt pleased about it so it was replaced by an oppo 105d bought back in 2015 and has been in service faith fully since monday...few minor glitches but never sent back...The sim was sent back because of drawer issue and was replaced (at my cost) and i have to say i dont remember it sounding as good back in 2008-2015 <>...They did a really great job.Clean no damage shipping or otherwise (kudos simaudio,thx)...and yes my oppo 105d is retired as of monday and really have alot of admiration for the product.Sooo good to have the sim back in the fold.
jrosemd
152 posts
 
I've had bad luck with a couple of NAD CD players which broke after less than five years.  Have had a Sony ES and two Marantz players that have lasted for several years.   The Sony DVP-NS 999ES has a really cheap and fragile tray that occasionally swallows a CD.  I had to remove the entire metal case to rescue the CD.  Otherwise, the Sony and the Two Marantz players play fine and sound excellent.    
surferandy's avatar
surferandy
52 posts
 
Shanling Tube output Player died after 2 years, Marantz 6005 has lasted and still going 4 years on. BUT has started to be fussy on which CDs it will play. I take care of my CD's as I do my LP's, but frequently played CD's often wont play on the Marantz but will play on the old Pioneer on the car.So I will say that the quality of CD's  themselves is a contributing factor, and I have well payed LP's 50 years old that play perfectly, but not CD's.
georgehifi's avatar
georgehifi
10,312 posts
 
I'll say it again, in case anyone missed my first post.

Never leave them powered up with a cd in them, this actives the laser and chews up it’s life expectancy very quickly.
Cheers George
mrf5
1 posts
 
I feel like I am one of the unlucky ones here and SACD/CD players are garbage the more you spend.  It seems the more I spend on a player, the quicker it dies.

Sony CDP-CE215 ($300 bucks back in 1995?) still works, my first CD player, I still own it
Panasonic portable CD player from the 90's....  Still works
Sony BDPS.....  It doesn't matter its still working and was cheap.

Pioneer DV45A ($500 lasted a couple years.)

Yamaha DVDS-2500 ($800, lasted a year)

Yamaha Adventage BD-A1060 ($500) lasted 18 months

Denon DVD-5910 ($5,000) DOA

McIntosh MCD-550 ($6,000) DOA

Seriously?  What gives?


More to discover