Poor grammar is disappointing and decidedly distracting in formal audio reviews.


I find the majority of formal audio reviews across numerous publications to be easy reads.  However, I can barely put together a coherent thought when reading anything by Jason Kennedy, editor of the-ear.net.  It is as if he does not understand the limitation of use of a comma.  Do the English really have that much of a different implementation of the english language versus Americans?  Does anybody else struggle to read certain editors' work?
mganga
As a grammarian and freelance proofreader, I say that poor grammar is disappointing and decidedly distracting in anything, especially anything online.
I'm old enough to remember back when it was considered proper to correct bad grammar right on the spot. It was never considered bad manners or insulting to do so and when I was corrected, it was not a big deal. In fact, I appreciated it and endeavored to remember it.

The English language is a beautiful thing to behold and I wish I were a lot better at it.

All the best,
Nonoise
I worked in the movie business for many years and I gotta say I've never come across a better collection of writers. It didn't matter whether the piece of writing was a novel, a screenplay or just an email to remind us of an upcoming holiday.
I’m old enough to remember back when it was considered proper to correct bad grammar right on the spot. It was never considered bad manners or insulting to do so and when I was corrected, it was not a big deal. In fact, I appreciated it and endeavored to remember it.

Yes but this was back before everyone was told they are a special snowflake, entitled to "their own truth" and that the best way of doing something isn’t really the best, you are just oppressing me, man!

Grammar is rules of language, how we use words. Earlier on another thread I lamented how there are similar rules of engagement for argument and inquiry. Not argument in the Monty Python sense, but argument in the sense of how you structure and say what it is that you want to say. Hardly anyone knows these rules any more either. The one thing they hate more than any other is rules- no worse, being told there ARE rules! Who are you to tell me.... etc etc yada yada.

But, there are. Following them is the difference between this
https://youtu.be/ohDB5gbtaEQ?t=86

and this-

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QVYGxSnLxJQ

now that my friends is an argument. Impeccable. Right down to the grammar.