@bdp24:
"Let's just call both (U.S.A.) Americans and Canadians as North Americans. ;-) ".
Sure. Why not?
"I would argue that in some ways Americans from the North (or at least non-South) have more in common with Canadians than they do with Southerners"
You could very well be right. I've almost no exposure to the South so I can't say. My wife and I have been on 3 vacations to Canada, though and we love it up there.
"Do people think of Neil Young as an American, or a Canadian? How about Joni Mitchell? Leonard Cohen?"
Tough calls for me. I'd bet all three were heavily influenced by American music but the question is: are their artistic sensibilities more Canadian or American? ? ? Above my pay grade, I'm afraid. That's perhaps a question for a serious academic.
"Let's just call both (U.S.A.) Americans and Canadians as North Americans. ;-) ".
Sure. Why not?
"I would argue that in some ways Americans from the North (or at least non-South) have more in common with Canadians than they do with Southerners"
You could very well be right. I've almost no exposure to the South so I can't say. My wife and I have been on 3 vacations to Canada, though and we love it up there.
"Do people think of Neil Young as an American, or a Canadian? How about Joni Mitchell? Leonard Cohen?"
Tough calls for me. I'd bet all three were heavily influenced by American music but the question is: are their artistic sensibilities more Canadian or American? ? ? Above my pay grade, I'm afraid. That's perhaps a question for a serious academic.