Great, great post, @prof!
The list of hi-fi engineers who operate(d) via the design with measurements/verify with listening methodology is a long one, including a couple of my favorites: Roger Modjeski (Music Reference, electronics) and Danny Richie (GR Research, loudspeakers).
The father of subjective reviewing---J. Gordon Holt---came from the engineering side of hi-fi, but considered listening "the proof in the pudding". When Harry Pearson appeared out of nowhere ten years after the first Stereophile was published and started The Absolute Sound---HP completely technically-ignorant (said in a non-pejorative spirit ;-)---measuring and technical analysis were conspicuously absent. No attempt was made to correlate design with sound quality, and in fact TAS sort of encouraged an attitude of the two being opposing forces. An unfortunate and counter-productive development.
Thank God for John Atkinson!
The list of hi-fi engineers who operate(d) via the design with measurements/verify with listening methodology is a long one, including a couple of my favorites: Roger Modjeski (Music Reference, electronics) and Danny Richie (GR Research, loudspeakers).
The father of subjective reviewing---J. Gordon Holt---came from the engineering side of hi-fi, but considered listening "the proof in the pudding". When Harry Pearson appeared out of nowhere ten years after the first Stereophile was published and started The Absolute Sound---HP completely technically-ignorant (said in a non-pejorative spirit ;-)---measuring and technical analysis were conspicuously absent. No attempt was made to correlate design with sound quality, and in fact TAS sort of encouraged an attitude of the two being opposing forces. An unfortunate and counter-productive development.
Thank God for John Atkinson!