Turntable and cartridge setup known for a marvelous bottom end.


I could use some advice. I am thinking on upgrading my Pro-Ject Classic turntable and Hana SH cartridge. My speakers are Monitor Audio Gold 300's. They go down to 30 which isn't quite a subwoofer spec, but because they are so darn close, I really don't want to complement them with one.

 

What I am thinking is rather that getting a sub, with your help I would upgrade my turntable setup with a turntable and cartridge that has been proven to have a wonderful bottom end.

So far my only guides have been the end of year rating in the audiophile magazines. For the most part these guides are over the place.

The only turntable that shows up in all the audiophile magazines is the very affordable Rega P-10. They all report that it is a splendid turntable, but not once have I heard of anyone marveling over its bottom end. I'd like to keep the $$$ down to around 10 grand. Thanks for your help.

 

The phono stage is Parasound JC3+ going to a Benchmark LA 4 pre-amp to a Benchmark AHB2 power amp.

Thanks

 

marshinski15

The Monitor Audio Gold 300's may say they go down to 30hz, but the specs say the do that at -6Db.  Loudness drops off by half for every 3Db reduction, so you're down to 25% of the volume of the higher frequencies at that point.  And you'd have to see the curve to see how far down it is at 50Hz.

There is really no speaker on earth - unless it includes a powered sub in it - that truly gives you all the bass.

You need a sub(s) and it doesn't matter a lot where you put it.  Your ears can't localize frequencies that low.  You might be able to put it beside you or behind you.

And as MillerCarbon notes, using multiple subs makes the placement irrelevant.

Here is a huge problem for you, 16 by 16 foot room, and even worse if the room has an 8 foot ceiling.

Never was a fan of the cheaper Pro-Ject turntables, but looking at a review of the new Pro-Ject Debut Pro makes me think this is a real winner at the entry level.

Some of the best MM cartridges from the dolgen age of analog can reproduce bass from 5Hz, I doubt there is anything like that on the record, but if you will look at the specs of the Audio-Technica AT-ML170 or 180 you will see frequency response of those marvelous cartridges: 5Hz - 42k Hz for AT-ML180 and 5Hz - 40kHz for AT-ML170. Those cartridges are spectacular.

Anyway, if you have bass issues you have to studdy room acoustics, it depends on your room size and position of your speakers (and your listening position). Do not change any gear until you will find a sweet spot in your room with your speakers. Various methods published online.