2. speakers
  3. 1340358044

Sophia 1 with McIntosh/Lamm tubes? Please advise

My system is now B&W 804S, McIntosh MC275 amp and Lamm LL2 preamp, and Rel Storm III sub. The Lamm was the latest addition about 1.5 years ago and I REALLY like it.

I'm thinking of a next upgrade, either the speakers or amp. If I were to upgrade amp today I would probably go with Lamm ML1 or M1.1 hybrid. However, I'm leaning towards upgrading speakers first. Right track? BTW, the following upgrade would be a couple years away.

My budget for speakers is $5-6k, maybe $7k if I can let the sub go. Thinking of buying used. I've been reading about Wilson Sophia 1, Merlin VSM, and DeVore Nines (Silverbacks likely beyond my budget). Do you think these would match well with tubes? The Sophias are 89 dB (vs my B&W at 91 dB), but said to play very well at moderate levels. I'm certainly open to other suggestions.

I really enjoy the sense of 3D spaciousness during playback, the "musicians in the room" holographic presentation. Absolute true tonal balance is less important to me, to the extent is not grossly off, of course. Musicality and high definition are important, and also bass extension and definition.

The room is 33x15x8 ft, speakers on a short side, spaced about 7.5 ft between them, and 5 ft from front wall. Listening position on an equilateral triangle.

Music tastes: all over the place, but mostly rock, blues and jazz. The dynamic range/impact the Sophias are said to have are appealing too.
lewinskih01
keithr
1,306 posts
 
BAT works super good with Sophia 1 imo. 75SEs are cheap (relatively)
lewinskih01 OP
909 posts
 
Missioncoonery: I looked at your past responses to get a better perspective of where you are coming from. I see you like tubes - saw a "Jadis user since '95" somewhere. Maybe it's the McIntosh you don't like. Which amps do you like with the Sophia 1?

I also saw you do like the Wilson Sasha and the Sophia 3. How good do you think the Sophia 1 is compared to others in the same price range? I saw you talk about Avalons. I really like what I see on reviews, but I'm concerned with their low sensitivity.

Anyway, thanks your your input. challenging but constructive replies help me make a better decision.

Gpgr4blu: thanks for the feedback/confirmation!
ricred1
2,043 posts
 
Lewinskih01,
I've been enjoying this hobby for over 20 years and the best advice I can give you is to take advice/opinions with a very big grain of salt. I have owned many speakers, including Sophia 2s, 3s, and now Sasha's. The Sasha's are by far the best speaker I've ever owned. I like forums because they can offer food for thought...meaning someone may mention a product that I never thought of. When I was searching to replace my Sophia 3S, I received and listened to many recommendations, but in the end my ears choose Sasha's. Decide on how much you want to spend and then try to listen to as many combinations as you can. You are listening to a system, more than individual components. The trick is to find a dealer that's capable of putting together a synergistic combination within your budget. Last I'll leave you with this, just because I love Sasha's, doesn't mean you or anyone else will love them...there are no absolutes in audio, only preferences! Let your ears choose!
gpgr4blu
1,088 posts
 
I agree with Ricred1. I too have owned a number of Wilson speakers including Sophias, Watt Puppy 7s and Sashas. Sashas are, to my ears, among the best speakers out there----at any price----. But they are a tough load in portions of the low end. Wilson critics disagree on the merits of the speakers of course.
IMHO Sophias are one of the best values in audio in their used price category. I remember listening to them with a Naim Nait at 15 wpc after I read an article by Robert Harley in which he said the combo worked. He was right. The Sophias can be driven by virtually anything. Listen for yourself if possible.
keithr
1,306 posts
 
People recommending Sashas clearly havent read the OPs budget recs.
More to discover