Personally I found Patricia Barber café blue recording too hi Fi, I mean it doesn't sound real for me, it's a bit sci Fi. But it might be my system, anyway, some of my reference recording that gives me goosebumps are this:
Sam Cooke / night beat
Inti illimani / lugares comunes
Sueye Park/ Paganini 24 caprices SACD
Ella and Louis SACD
Simone kopmajer / live at Heidi
Very common but still... Nils lofgren/ acoustic live
Jacques lousier/ the best of play Bach SACD
Pink Floyd/ the wall and animals