@flasd - yes, you are going to hear a big difference. How could you not hear a big difference given the two very different turntables & associated equipment that was in use?
Two questions (at least)
- Is the difference worth what you are about to set in motion? Specifically, an entry level rig to a rig & peripherals that will run you several thousand.
- Is the EAT the turntable for you in the end? I view EATs as the next level up from Pro-ject TTs, and that is because of the same family ownership of both brands.
I wouldn’t jump on the EAT right away. I would probably try a new cartridge like the Ortofon Blue. It is that good a cartridge, especially given your set-up.
What I would spend time with is looking at different makes of TTs and find what you really like & want in a TT. Miller Carbon is correct as the TT is more than just a component. If you hit it right, you will keep it a very long time.
I went through something similar myself about 6 years back, when I started with a Stanton 150 TT and went through a few purchases before I landed on the new series Technics 1210. Many cartridges along the way, as well. In my above post, I am on the list for a Decware phono preamp.
A key feature for me is bayonet cartridge head-shells, so I can try different cartridges easily. A Project or EAT arm would not work for me. I also like Direct Drive TTs. Once I mentally accepted the cost involved in getting a good DD turntable and pulled the trigger, I stopped shopping.
Good luck,
Rich