Nietzsche and Runaway Audio Consumption


Came across this today. A lot of posts bring up the issue of "how much is enough?" or "when is audio consumption justified" etc.

Does this Nietzsche aphorism apply to audio buying? You be the judge! 

Friedrich Nietzsche“Danger in riches. — Only he who has spirit ought to have possessions: otherwise possessions are a public danger. For the possessor who does not know how to make use of the free time which his possessions could purchase him will always continue to strive after possessions: this striving will constitute his entertainment, his strategy in his war against boredom. 

Thus in the end the moderate possessions that would suffice the man of spirit are transformed into actual riches – riches which are in fact the glittering product of spiritual dependence and poverty. They only appear quite different from what their wretched origin would lead one to expect because they are able to mask themselves with art and culture: for they are, of course, able to purchase masks. By this means they arouse envy in the poorer and the uncultivated – who at bottom are envying culture and fail to recognize the masks as masks – and gradually prepare a social revolution: for gilded vulgarity and histrionic self-inflation in a supposed ‘enjoyment of culture’ instil into the latter the idea ‘it is only a matter of money’ – whereas, while it is to some extent a matter of money, it is much more a matter of spirit.” 

Nietzsche, Friedrich. 1996. Human, All Too Human: A Book for Free Spirits. Cambridge University Press. (p. 283-4, an aphorism no. 310)

I'm pretty sure @mahgister will want to read this one! (Because they speak so artfully about avoiding the diversion that consumption poses to the quest for true aesthetic and acoustic excellence.)

128x128hilde45

I will made an another apology to all for my posts here telling a story....

One day a french doctor who was a devoted christian but was interested in Zen and in martial art visited not long after the second world war a monastery of Zen Buddhism directed by a great master...

The young french doctor speaking about the christian virtues of charity and explaining why he was interested by zen and martial art but will never convert to Buddhism because love and charity is for him the essential above anything was very surprized when the monk reply: "you are totally right and i do not recommend that you change the great teaching of Christ for the Buddha, but the most important virtue is humility, because if you give rice to someone by force and not waiting humbly  for his hand to open itself the rice will fall on the dust and will be lost"...

i read that and i was stunned  and discover immediately that i lack humility and in this thread i did it  again putting posts without waiting for any question...

it seems old ape are tough to reform...

Happy new year to all....

Thanks i am very happy that you had like my article post...

Egoistically to save my posts frenzy from delirium crisis hypothesis by some, and because almost no one seems to be interested in thinking here save a few ...

Like in the audio hobby they buy ideology  and upgrade BEFORE thinking and studying acoustic....N. was right....I like very much the OP use of N. lucidity...

Without the OP no discussion about spirit/ music/ consumerism and others "miracles" and "conspiracy" or mass manipulation would have been possible in audiogon...Thanks to him....

And in this crisis times we must think together... Not one against the other....

 

Great article.

The relentless intrusion of the corporate world into the scientific one is one there doesn’t seem to be any protection against.

It’s appalling to think that global leaders are now reduced to acting as sales reps for big pharma.

 

Music is a 2 way power...

Something that put all of us on a "spell"...A mass hypnosis tool...

A deceptive rapture of our mind and soul...music is a tool for control in all armies and publicities of the world for example...

But music is also a tool to heal us like any drug who comes from a poison or could be one if dose is not right, is designed to be a bliss and a "rapture" in heaven or toward spirit like in native people or religious ceremony... Or like used in therapeutic...Or written to elevate the brain OUT of itself like in Bach...

 

Money also is born like any poison, a destructive agent, but also a "pharmakon" a possible remedy...

Spin doctors, "eminence grise" plays on these two modalities for music like for money...

Fritz Lang probably never read Bernard Mandeville, but his Dr. Mabuse is a perfect allegory between the "nevrosis" of those under a spell and the "perversion" coming from those who look for controls...Like in Mandeville Hive allegory...

Art may be more powerful than Science...I repeat: Art MAY BE more powerful than science...

Because science is divided in many fields, and each fiels is divided in an indefinite number of skills and specialities...No scientist can create a synthesis , the price to pay is loosing his scientist status...The artist could and must, true art is always a SYMBOLIC SYNTHESIS, never only an entertainment or a provocation...

Knowledge is not science, science is not technology...

Art may integrate knowledge, science and technology sometimes revealing some aspects of their possible integration or contradictions.. Like a philosophy inspired by spirit can do it...Like some man also driven by a spiritual quest....like a scientis who is also an artist and a spiritual man...

A Swiss economist wrote a book about the relation between money and economy inspired by the Goethe Faust for example...

https://www.deepdyve.com/lp/duke-university-press/money-and-magic-a-critique-of-the-modern-economy-in-the-light-of-qw787UpvP1

N. was right speaking of the spirit and the weight and unrecognized burden of the material possessions, but for N. what he call the owner of spirit MUST be read in these 2 way manner: the owner of the spirit could the master who control himself first but the master mind who can " fall" into the role of leading the mass with the deceptive offer of marketting illusions, with money, with a "spin" mass art who will put people to sleepwalking...These 2 way to understand N. put N. himself in an impossible doublebind situation at the end...

Religion is not the only opium, money is another one...N. seeing all the hypocrisy of religion putting man on a sleep and reading Darwin, thought that a man is free only when he liberate himself alone over his apeness : the ubermensch...But this freeing by oneself alone is also an illusion explained in Buddhism and in Christianity alike...Schopenhauer never FORGOT that lesson contrary to his disciple Nietszche...

N. after all was himself a genius under a spell....

Doistoievsky never was... Nor Goethe....

 

@snilf

May you give me ( us ) , some names of good quality recording Cello music.

Cello and English Horn have become my prefered instruments .


I am dependant of my audio gear’s possession .

But I use streaming ( Tidal )  . No CD 

thanks