Holmz: Yes it is elliptical and it sounds great to my ears. Both L and R are clear and it's tracking well. I really can't compare it to anything other than spotify though..
If it sound as good or better than Spotify, then you are doing good.
DeKay: I am unfamiliar with SME. Is that the type of tonearm I have? I will definitely experiment with a lp under the mat and see if it sounds better then go from there
Thank you all for the great advice. I'm learning a lot
I would suggest that you clean the oily old mat… That may work better for the standard LPs.
The new mat being thinner would be good for the thicker 180gr jobs… and then both thicknesses would be at about the same level… in case you shim or otherwise get a perfect SRA.
Like this @dekay fellow:
As adjusting the arm height on my current SME 3009 non-improved is a PITA I set it up for average thickness LP's and I use a lifter/under mat for thinner LP's (the thinner one's are generally "import" LP's from Europe issued in the 70's/early 80's).