The Law of Accelerating Returns


I totally agree this letter from the editor of A-S.

It makes sense if you have a $10,000 high quality integrated and stick a   $500.00 TT with a $300 phono section, a $400,00 Topping DAC and stream through your phone you will never know the real potential of the $10K integrated. And don't get me going on speakers. 

This article makes total sense but one must live within their means. 

No you do not have to spend a left lung for great sound but it all needs to be balanced. 

 

128x128jerryg123

Yesterday I adjusted the crossover setting on my subwoofer and changed its position relative to the front wall. Let's say the crossover adjustment applied about 50 cents worth of time and effort to a $20K system.  The bass response  improvement may not have been as great as adding a subwoofer in the first place, but then, the cost was far far less. 

However, the "law" won't necessarily apply if you just start fiddling with dials (or spending money). You first need to identify where your system needs improvement (for example, in the sounds of kick drums.)  

 

Helmholtz treatment "only" work on ONE frequency and to bring down a peak in that very specific frequency and nothing more or less.

 

NO! they can be used to notch around a frequency. To contour a particular frequency or by using slot vs tube vary a single resonator to encompass several frequencies with less control but over a much wider bandwidth. 

Helmholtz is the ONLY way to tune a room completely. 

I've even used passive radiators as frequency collectors vs frequency producers. 

The concept can be used to increase a given frequency by notching around it and lowering the over all SPL. I use several different resonators and  two huge 100+ cubic foot pipe collectors. It looks like a pipe organ turned sideways in both corners of the front wall, floor to ceiling 36 x 36 x 96" but they are behind the wall. Different diameter ABS tubes are sticking out of the wall.

Many of the tubes are capped, about 1/3 aren't, the ones that ARE capped are used to diffuse, the ones that are not, are used for tuning. You simply push or pull them further in or out of the wall. You pick the correct size 1/2" - 6" pipe uncap it and tune it. I also use 4 more adjustable tube traps for the rear and sides, with slot style wall resonators for fine tuning.

You can hear a fly fart if you want.. :-) I think that would be in the 18khz range.. LOL

10hz to 15khz 100% tunable..

BTW ALL the traps on the walls and floor are decoupled from the wall and floor..

Speakers, Subs, and any object with equipment on it.. (Especially TTs) are decoupled. A sound changing experience for life. The same for servo driver systems and small planars.. A different sound that is very appealing to me..

Equipment? Gear? Take your pick and go from there. After the ROOM everything else is pretty superficial. All those thing that did make such a big difference before don't amount to a hill of beans.. 10K integrated means squat then, when a 2K total system will sound better. It's the room and tuning it along with decoupling and refining the quality even more.

Did I mention electrical? :-) This is when "Doris get's her oats".

Room tuning may be something an obsessive/compulsive listener could chase around until they're ready to gloat about it (I think rooms generally can add a sense of realism with only furnishings and regular stuff, unless maybe your room is an abandoned shipping container), or not. What anybody likes or doesn't like about the sound of a system is utterly due to personal taste, and in my experience that seems to vary wildly. My current system of relatively modest items chosen and kept or rejected and replaced, seems astonishingly better sounding than any I've heard anywhere at any price mostly because it's there by and for me. I hear some interesting improvements from cables or amps getting their legs after break-in, but that's simply fun and not a huge deal. Unless I need to gloat.

@helmholtzsoul I clerified the simplified short version. We are on the same page.

It is not the "ONLY" way to tune a room completely.

Is it not better to NOT push power into frequencies that the room gets excited about because its dimensions and positions of speakers and sweet spot? Of course it is.

 

The Helmholtz for example is a fix on something that is after that we have created the issue.

But it so a good treatment technology to have in the toolbox.

The bottom line is who care about money of components or synergy of the level of the same, if the room is untreated.

 

It is funny to see the focus on price, the results is audiophiles bringing whole their life gear in and out of the same poor room. And expecting a better results.. ..but they just get different results.

 Talking about "sideways" moves.