33rpm vs 45rpm - which is better


Growing up, I was a big Peanuts comics fan including Vince Guaraldi’s music.

Recently, a remastered from tape “Great Pumpkin” vinyl was announced in both 331/3rpm and 45rpm, both are a single LP each at Elusive Disc. Both albums have the same number of songs.

It seems that playing slower allows for wider grooves, while faster may mean longer grooves. If so, I’ve no clue which one is better.

Which version offer the best sonics?

 

 

 

kennyc

I was taught by the various audio magazines that 33rpm LP was the best available format for sonics, and yet when a friend bought round his 45rpm 12 inch single of Duran Duran's 'The Wild Boys' the dynamics were something my Linn/Naim system had never before conveyed.

 

In fact I can't recall hearing a poor sounding 12 inch 45rpm single. Therefore my vote goes to the 45rpm.

Sonically the 45 should be superior to the 33 1/3 pressing especially if mastered by Kevin Gray. And personally, I wouldn't buy an orange record.

45 rpm without any debate.  The faster the record spins, the longer the groove length per unit (note, whatever) and therefore the greater the resolution.  Period.

33 rpm is simply a trade off between fidelity and long playing. Note the 33 1/3, whcih replaced 45s and 78 is called the "LP".  not the "good quality".

Same with tape where 15 ips >> 7 1/2 ips >> 3 3/4 ips >> cassette

Basic physics.  and a rule int he record industry.

That said it will take more sides to achieve the same number of songs.

The Tidal version is excellent.  Far simpler :-0

 

I don't know why the 45rpm is not on multiple discs like so many other vinyl reissues of late. Cost, I guess?🤔