@sns ,
No, not really. It is more an argument between made up and real.
For instance, one of the people arguing believes that they could tell the difference between $1/4 million of audio equipment either hooked up or not hooked up to a very high end inverters when listened to over Youtube at 192kbps AAC, when the issues between the two videos included auto levelling applied to both videos by Youtube, what appears to be an object blocking one speaker in one of the videos resulting in both a level shift and a significant frequency shift in one channel (I assume a person standing in the wrong spot), what appears to be AGC pumping (the noise floor was pumping +/-3 db which will bring low level signals along with it), and that was coupled with a high amount of reverb.
It does not matter if you are purely subjective, purely objective, or somewhere in the middle. Any reasonable person will understand the ability to accurately pull a super subtle difference between two setups out of low resolution highly flawed videos such as those is not being honest with themselves.