Powered speakers show audiophiles are confused

@donavabdear do you have a room response comparison for your two systems?  I would not be surprised if the difference is more frequency response than anything.

Also I have what should be a very good headphone setup, Focal Stellia and a Naim amp designed for headphones. the headphones and amp were about $8k 

The headphones sound ok they have never really thrilled me. I thought having expensive headphones and a dedicated class A amp would change my life. It's good but nope.

@thespeakerdude : what are YOUR speaker(s)? Cin. Thanks

OP,

I also have a good headphone system. While I occasionally use my Focal Utopias, which sound amazing, I normally use my Sennheiser HD800’s. My system is amazing and incredibly musical and natural… the amp is a Woo 300B (my systems under my ID). It is so good it caused me to completely redo my main system with all tubed components.

@donavabdear

You resolved the confusion, when not sure to get active or passive, get both. 😀

That is only partly funny because I did the same thing. Active in my HT and desktop, passive in the man cave. They are all fun, and different.

@brianlucey got me thinking about my next build. I never gave Atmos in headphones much thought. I never gave Atmos and analog much thought. His posts made me think. I think I want to build an Atmos/analog tube based headphone rig as my next "system". Jim Fosgate and Black Ice audio collaborated on a SOA headphone amp that they demoed at CEDIA 2022. Will see what happens once it is released. The FOZ says it is his finest creation, how everything he has done before has led him here. I have never done tubes or headphones seriously, hopefully this will be a good introduction to both.