Totally Ridiculous....Auditions on YouTube!


Is it just me, or is it total nonsense when YouTubers play music to suggest you can hear a difference between components. Totally drives me crazy and I discount anything they have to offer from that point on......

rbertalotto

You can hear a difference on YouTube, especially if it's a big difference. I was watching Mr. Carlson's lab and I could definitely hear a difference when he switched microphones. He always used a good microphone, but when he switched to a high quality tube microphone it sounded much better.

@ozzy62

A difference is a difference no matter how bad the room or acoustics are. You might not hear a component or speaker perform at its potential, but if you can hear an improvement (or the other way) when something is swapped out, then it exists.

 

I think so too.

It’s unfortunate that since Google’s acquisition of YouTube in 2006 the highest bitrate offered has been 192kbs (2012/13).

You would have thought that it would been upgraded since then, but alas, no.

As of late 2022 only premium subscribers can get 256kbps, everyone else gets 128kbs.

Hopefully that situation will change in the near future.

Actually, things aren’t as bad as some might like to make out.

Some audiophile channels do offer high bitrate downloads which you can then use to compare any potential differences between playback equipment - or not.

 

In any case, for better or worse, a YouTube video will always carry considerably more weight than any article written by a reviewer.

That fact alone makes well recorded online demonstrations a serious alternative source of information interested in sound quality.

Even at the lowly 128kbps significant sonic differences can be easily heard through a pair of (hopefully) neutral loudspeakers or even better, headphones.

Its not about bit rate… its about the recording microphone being used and the playback equipment on the other end. No way on Gods green earth can anyone accertain anything from these videos.

Every man takes the limits of his own field of vision for the limits of the world. - -Arthur Schopenhauer

No way on Gods green earth can anyone accertain anything from these videos.

And on facebook.  When someone posts a video of their speakers I respond that they sound just like Laptop speakers to me.