Magico A3 vs. Wilson SabrinaX


Well, coming down the stretch, I can't find a on this forum comparing these 2 speakers. I listened to the SabrinaX, and found them "flat" somehow, hard to describe. Incredible definition and soundstage, but not much knack/dynamic. So, I'm wondering how they would compare to the Magico A3s that I haven't had a chance to listen to. I would be pairing these with a Pass XA25 which should be sufficient to drive them. Or is my "flat" experience simply unrealistic?
trackmoe

Really? And how do you know that? Have you compared them in the same circuit?? Rel caps were always mediocre, and have not changed in decades. Comparing the Sabrina to the A is like comparing a Chevy to a Porsche. True, the A5 is better then the A3 (A friend of mine just replaced his Sasha DAW with an A5)

Wow, replacing Sasha DAW? I DREAM of these speakers!! Why selling them, I’m curious about this. Switching seems a radical step in sound change, no?

He visited me too many times and heard the A5 😉
He ordered the new S3 but, in the meantime, bought an A5. The DAW are gone!
And yes, it is a significant change in sound (quality, that is).

I have the Sabrina X’s powered by the Pass Labs 250.8.  The Pass gives them all of the power that they need and mine sound both detailed and dynamic.  Remember, what any speaker sounds like is also dependent on the rest of the system and cabling, AND room placement/room treatment.  With a bad room, great speakers can sound much less than their potential.  Because of my room size (11x11) I don’t have a lot of choices for speaker placement, but with the proper equipment, the Wilsons are stellar in my system.  They do need some power though.  My PrimaLuna Dialogue Premier HP tube amp could drive them adequately, but the Pass makes them sing.

Lots of information here and lots of conflicting ears.  The A5 is the speaker to audition not the A3.  Wilsons are usually set-up for only one listener but that may not matter to you.  The new Wilsons are now designed to be a more musical speaker as is the A5.  I have heard both at length.  It comes down to preference as both do what they do and have different sonic attributes.