The golden age of LPs was 1950s, early 1960s. They took trouble and the raw material was purer. Best is to collect these.
'Audiophile' reissues in my experience are of VERY variable quality. Most early MoFis are excellent. Good example of many is Beatles For Sale - Lennon is singing in the room.
Everything else is very variable. Some are dire and I hate myself for having been taken in to spend big money on a disc a lot worse than the original. Unfortunately apart from listening and (possibly) review, there is no way of knowing beforehand.