New sound immersion processes


What is everyone’s thoughts on these new sound immersion processes?  Do you like Dolby Atmos and Sony 360 Reality audio?  Do you like one better than the other? Or neither? Do you listen via headphones or thru your rig? 

polkalover

@erik_squires 

Atmos sounds fine through two speakers, I don't see why you can't have both? I have a very nice DAC for streaming stereo, I can upmix to Dolby Surround if I want.

I have a very nice processor for Atmos, I can play Atmos mix through two speakers if I want.

 

BTW, the most immersive system I ever had was a 5.1 and what made it sound like you were absolutely engulfed in the sound field wasn't more speakers but ceiling treatment.

+1 on ceiling treatment, look at the pics in my virtual system, I have absorbers in the front. a combo diffuser/bass trap above the MLP, and an acoustic "cloud" near the back.

I think the adoption of immersive audio formats is tightly linked to the effect of critical mass. Critical mass of records. Critical mass of gear.

Indeed, listening to a well-mixed Dolby Atmos record through an audio system built to Dolby specs is very pleasant, and in some ways superior to stereo experience on any system imaginable. Like Sergeant Pepper's I once heard at Dolby headquarters.

Still, even though I have a decent Dolby Atmos system at home, most of records I like listening to are still in stereo, and most of those are not likely to ever be remixed.

I tend to think that online audio suppressed the timely adoption of physical multi-channel audio media, such as SACD. Just when SACD hobby were becoming interesting, the ability to listen to almost any stereo-recorded music mankind ever produced, for a reasonable fee, overrode the enjoyment derived from a limited selection of SACD records.