The Impossible Has Happened


If you've been visiting this forum for very long you know that many people consider professional audio reviews, the ones in the print (Stereophile, TAS, etc.) and online magazines, at best to be paid promotion and more likely outright lies in an attempt to scam you out of your money.

Here is a quote from a recent thread that was about reviews, not about their honesty or value, but got a number of posts about those attributes anyway.

Just once I would like to read a review of a pricey piece of equipment that said that the reviewer couldn’t hear any difference between that and something far less expensive . . .

Well believe it or not that has just happened in TAS, considered by many to be the worst abuser of the truth. The situation is not exactly as in the quote above, the less expensive gear is being reviewed in this example, but it is the same in essence, IMHO.

Alan Taffel wrote a review of the T+A Series 200 components.  In it he says 

"I happen to own a wonderful-sounding modular integrated amp: the CH Precision I1.  Comparing it to the Series 200 was natural but a bit unfair.  The CH unit costs more than double the price of the Series 200 stack.  Nonetheless, I was glad I embarked on this comparison, because otherwise I never would have known that the two systems sounded almost identical."

 

The CH I1 starts at $38,000.  Fully loaded it costs over $50,000..

The Series 200 stack, consisting of a transport/streamer, a DAC and an integrated amp in 3 separate boxes, costs $18,475.

So I'm not saying you should believe everything you read in professional reviews or even any of it, but here is an example where a reviewer stated that a system costing less than half a more expensive system sounded "almost identical" to the more expensive system. 

And CH Precision has a full page ad in that issue of TAS, February 2023, while T+A has none.  Just thought you might like to know.

128x128tomcy6

and for the subject, why would any professional reviewer say anything bad about an item the manufacturer lent them? I have read car reviews for three decades now. The way to find out the truth about the car is not when it comes out and gets 5 star reviews but 2 years later when they put it in a 4 car comparison review (one HAS to be 4th) and they write the truth about 3, except the one that just came out (and was lent to them for a round of reviews).  

Maybe, maybe there will be 2 models, to be the exception to this that they will never criticize. 

Back in 1992 Cory Green Greenberg for Stereophile Mag wrote a rather negative review of the Scientific Fidelity Tesla Speaker that some audiophiles claim put SF out of business.

DO you think a person who is both eyes blind can see the difference between yellow color and orange color?

We, all human being, as aged (ca. 55 years or older), are suppose to lose hearing ability, especially high frequency such as 4kHz or higher. 

One professional audio reviewer (about 60 years old) says Amp A is more open at the extreme audio band while Amp B is less open. Can you trust what he says?

Just ridiculous. Please, let's neither believe nor trust him!

I would like to rather believe a blind person's description about nice sky color.

 

 

....without taking the time to 'edit' and add audioexotica v. the screen....all the elder listeners are subject to this to varied degrees.  Not mentioning 'selective listening' (ask your spouse/SO....and get another sort of earfull...;) *L*)

I also receive a number of real estate listing from Red Fin every day to find out what homes are selling for in my area.  I have yet to see a single home with a pair of floor standing speakers in a room.  This includes homes priced over $6 million.  This said, do less than 1% buy sound systems.  I also see TV's and not a single TV has surround speakers.

@larry5729, it's impossible to make any judgement based on real estate sales photos, because the property is often professionally staged for sale. That means emptying the house, doing cosmetic things like cleaning, painting and new window shades, and bringing in nice, clean furniture for show (and the sellers have already moved out). Staging with floor standers and surround isn't going to help sell the property.

That said, there is nobody in my personal life (co-workers, friends, neighbors, extended family) with a nice audio or surround setup. I would say that less than 0.1% care enough to spend money on it.