Which turntable to keep?

Thanks for the input, everyone. Both units were given to me by my elderly dad when he downsized, so there's no diff in sentimental value between the two. I have no interest in spending more to upgrade since my wife insisted on built-in speakers in our home since she didn't want to see speakers sitting in the room. In other words, it's far from a setup that would benefit from a top end TT. Sounds like I'll be keeping the Dual.

Good choice. If it's in good shape, the Dual will do you right!

Happy wife happy life!  

I built vintage stereo system, she choose speakers that matched the living room. Setup a single power button and she can use her phone to play amazon music. 

Problem solved lol :)