I have to agree the Beatles in my opinion are a pop band, with one or two rock songs in their locker, all music is not Pop, it not all rooted in Rock n roll, pop is a mainstream popular music, a great deal of rock music is born from the blues, Metallica is not Pop they are a massive metal band but you wouldn’t define them as being popular with all listeners yet my favourite band, Jazz also is not Pop as it’s not popular across the board and I’ll vouch for that as I can listen to the stuff.
You wouldn’t declare One Direction, Take That, Coldplay rock bands.
What is the VERY BEST CD album you've ever heard?
Just like with records, I came across releases on CD that were never popular, but bring lots of interesting music and so I started collecting CDs that do have collectible value for the reason of a great and rare music presented.
So far album "Sauce Hollandaise" by Ashra is on my #1 desirable list
"Best Band You've Never Heard In Your Life" by Frank Zappa is my 2nd best CD I've ever heard.
- ...
- 119 posts total
To really hear and “show off” what my system can do it’s Diana Krall’s “The Girl in the Other Room”. Plus every single song is just so emotionally involving especially “Departure Bay” the last song on the CD. It’s honestly the one CD I play in it’s entirety and sit with my eyes shut and do not move… For just pure jammin out it’s undoubtedly Iron Maiden “Live After Death”! 🤟🏻🤟🏻 Man that one is truly timeless!😂 |
@mrmeaner Once again, as we see in this thread here, someone made a fuss about calling the Beatles, “rock.” Who cares? We all know the Beatles. Nothing bad is going to happen, no egregious misappropriation occurs if someone calls the Beatles “rock,” or “pop,” or whatever. It’s all madeup label malarkey anyway. It’s all pop. Metallica has sold 125 million albums. One is free to call this stuff whatever they want. People either are brainwashed by all the marketing labels and accept them as “fact” or “truth,” just really enjoy segregating and labeling things, reflexively equate “pop” with “bad,” or some combination of all the above. |
I think of a couple of releases that seem to me be creatures of the CD era: The Centennial edition of The Complete Robert Johnson brought out sounds I don't think anyone ever knew were there. Though I don't know that it's any great shakes sonically, the 1988 studio cast recording of Show Boat was a revelatory document of what was possibly the greatest American musical. Another monument of the CD is the encyclopedic box set: the Bear Family collections of Uncle Dave Macon, Louis Jordan and Bob Wills, the Bluebird Fats Waller and the Fremeaux Integrale Charles Trenet are particular prizes to me. This rock vs. pop thing is obviously some sort of snobbery but I can't quite see what it's being snobbish about. |
It’s absolutely not a snobbery thing, if your a jazz fan and someone said it’s just pop music plenty would say something. My wife’s mother & uncle was at the Cavern to first night the Beatles played there and many nights after and even they can define rock & pop. as for a stand out cd Seeds of Love from Tears for Fears is one of those for me. |
- 119 posts total