Is a home theater even worth it or doable?


Please be honest with me. I'm a huge TV  movie fan as I'm sure many of you are, and in my youth I used to have a Denon setup, blu-ray, etc. I loved the experience. Fast forward 25 years and now I just stream my tv and movies off Netflix, HBO Max, and Hulu. We are doing a new addition where we have an open space concept. I see myself continuing to stream in the future, but would like a clean sound at least. I am treating myself to an 85" TV not sure the make model yet, but I want a big one. Does it make sense for me to even invest in something more then a sound bar given my streaming and open concept? If so, what type of setup should I consider or if I should prewire something up and where would that be? Thanks for your advice.
 

cody012

cody012

I'll give my 2 cents.  My brother has a 65" OLED and a $2000 setup with a good-quality sound bar and 2 small subwoofers.  These are run by his TV. 

I have a 4K 7.1 system.  Same TV model but a Marantz Pre-Pro with separate amps, speakers, and subwoofer.  I would call my system the upper middle of the road.  

Can I hear the difference?  Yes, very easily.

Would I be happy with his system?  Definitely not for movies, maybe for television 

shows, but I doubt it.

After spending the money and listening to my system, have I ever wished I had done something cheaper?  No.

Can my wife tell the difference?  Yes 

Is that a good thing?  Yes, I would say mandatory.

It is just a matter of what you want in life and how much time you spend in front of your TV in a week.

Yu Da Boss!

If you have the space and budget I would highly recommend it. I have a 5.1 home theater system with matching Wharfdale towers, center channel, bookshelves for the surrounds and a Velodyne sub. A majority of streaming content on Netflix, Amazon Prime and Hulu have a 5.1 Dolby Digital soundtrack and a lot of Blu-Rays have Dolby Digital HD or DTS HD soundtracks which are even better. I also use my home theater system to listen to multi-channel SACDs, Blu-Ray audio, and DVD audio music. I would recommend purchasing the speakers front L&R, center, surrounds, and sub as a matched set if possible for uniform sound.

i dismantled my living room theater 1 1/2 years ago, and man i miss it. big Legacy front 3, psb surrounds and back. 2 velodyne DD12+ subs. heaven....i wanted my living room back with very nice 2 channel. also, it's not all about earthquake shake and boom. Breaking Bad in 7.2 sound is indescribably great, as one example........

I have a tannoy home theater kit, 5 satellites and a sub, run by a nice sony amp. Sounds great! I play DVD, bluray, and 4k through the oppo 103.

@cody012

Some advice from a guy who’s been designing and installing home theater systems before the term "home theater" existed. Think "Kloss Novabeam".

Audiophiles have some reverence for the artists and composers who created the work. When we’re fully resonating with the performance we make the connection between ourselves and the creative genius behind what we are experiencing. To classfy this is "special" is an understatement. That’s why we throw real money and time into assembling these purveyors of art.

"Movie buffs" have a similar admiration for the work and those who created it. Someone wrote a story. Someone thought story was interesting enough to develop it into a movie. What follows is a screenplay and an accumulation of talent that in some cases produces a piece that will live on thru the millennia. Wardrobe, casting, lighting, sound, and actors and actresses who don’t just play the part, but become the part. Just like an epic recording where all the stars line up and everyone involved reaches deep inside and produces the best performances of their lifetime, we are "gifted" with something truly unique that may happen on once in a lifetime.

I view "home theater" as something a couple of ’pay grades" above the "A-ticket amusement park ride" that is often attributed to "home theater". Don’t get me wrong, being pinned back into your seat as sounds whirl around you can be pretty amazing. But, that’s a small, narrow view of watching movies at home.

The target objective for "home theater" is in the form of a question: "Did the writer’s story get told?" Were all of the creative elements portrayed in my home to a degree where I "got it" and felt like "I was there?"

Some of my favorite (and, most effective) demos were of simple restaurant scenes where "nothing is going on" except dialog between the two main characters. Enter the high-performance surround sound system. You hear other conversations. The clanking of glasses and silverware, and the sense of the space the characters are in. Not to mention that the dialong between the charactiers is highly intelligible, and the emotion of the charactiers is presented more accurately. Extend this level of performance to more complex (and, engergetic) scenes and you get the sense of what "home theater" is all about. Low performing system don’t even come close.

Some of the impactful music ever written just happens to be on movie soundtracks. The movie Stardust is a fun ride, with an excellent cliassical music soundtrack, for example.

As for equipment, I’ll start with subwoofers:

Activity on the screen is happening at the speed of light. Sloppy cones just can’t keep up with it. The flash of an explosion happens on the screen and is gone before the sound get to us, then lingers far after the moment of visual impact departs. You’re supposed to be startled, yet what you are experiencing is a slow motion, time-delayed portrayal of the event. It takes real power and precision for a subwoofer to do its job -- correctly. It takes quality AND quantity. Not easy to do on a tight budget. But, do the best you can. Just don’t overlook this aspect of system performance.

Receivers can do a decent job of putting you there. I’d recommend experiencing "better stuff" to see if the investment is worth the money for you. Higher resolution results in more information in the space. Your ears (and brain) may appreciate the difference.

So, in my view, the heros of the "home theater system" are those who create the content. Movie lovers may want to be just as committed to "getting it right" as we are with our music systems. That is IF we want the storyteller’s story to be accurately "told" in our homes.