Cartridge question


I have a Yamaha YP D6 Turntable .

I have 3 cartridges. Which should I choose?

Shure M75CS  or 

ADC ( no model #)  or 

Stanton 500 V3

Opinions please.

rocky1313

viridian

"

I have some stylus articles that Namiki published when they introduced the Microridge (also known as microline among other names) profile, so let's look at the manufacturer's figures.

A 0.7mil spherical stylus (18um radius where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 30.5um(sq.) - one wall.

A 0.5mil spherical stylus (13um radius where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 23.4um(sq.) - one wall.

A 0.3x0.7mil elliptical stylus (18umx6um radii where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 20.6um(sq.) - one wall.

A line-contact stylus (45umx6um radii where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 46.7um(sq.) - one wall.

A microridge stylus (75umx2.5um radii where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 62.1um(sq.) - one wall.

hth, jonathan carr"

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

so line contact is +57% more contact surface than spherical

microridge is +100% more contact surface than spherical

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

IF correct about elliptical (really?)

line contact is +130% more contact surface than elliptical

microridge is +210% more contact surface than elliptical

then there's SAS; Shibata; van den Hul; gyger 2; ........

Post removed 

Dear Viridian :  Gyger makes the Replicant 100 for Ortofon and in its site you can read the Replicant 100 specs and use a radius of 100, that's why the name Replicant 100.

Giger makes other model ( s) with bigguer radius. Here you can read the overall information about coming from an expert retipper:

 

https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/replicant-100-stylus/post?postid=2326742#2326742

 

https://www.ortofon.com/mc-diamond-p-1000-n-1579

 

R.

Post removed 

viridian

chart below indicates what is normally understood: elliptical has MORE contact area than Spherical

 

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

I have to believe Johnathan Carr made a typo in the comments you cited

"I have some stylus articles that Namiki published when they introduced the Microridge (also known as microline among other names) profile, so let's look at the manufacturer's figures.

A 0.7mil spherical stylus (18um radius where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 30.5um(sq.) - one wall.

A 0.5mil spherical stylus (13um radius where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 23.4um(sq.) - one wall.

A 0.3x0.7mil elliptical stylus (18umx6um radii where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 20.6um(sq.) - one wall."

**** chart above shows .3 x .7 = 40um****

which fits common understanding

"A line-contact stylus (45umx6um radii where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 46.7um(sq.) - one wall.

A microridge stylus (75umx2.5um radii where the stylus contacts the groove) has a contact area of 62.1um(sq.) - one wall."

hth, jonathan carr