Stills wrote song great songs, but come on, this is like comparing the 1985 Los Angeles Lakers to the Washington Generals. Neil Young is in a small handful of the greatest songwriters in rock and roll history, having recorded at least half a dozen albums that are widely and rightly considered among the best rock records ever made. Relatively speaking, Stills isn't much more than a footnote.
- ...
- 56 posts total
@rpeluso - if you like the album, and particularly if you like Sugar Babe, then you have to read this: https://lefsetz.com/wordpress/2023/05/29/sugar-babe-live-at-berkeley-1971/ |
@hickamore You are preaching to the choir. Powderfinger is tour de force and a favorite of mine. It's kind of silly debating who's the better songwriter. We all have our favorites and no one is likely to change their minds. But still, through the decades, I have been blown ways over and over by the mastery that is Neil Youngs song writing. From the complexity of Crime in the City (Freedom) or the simple lines from On The Beach "Though my problems are meaningless, That don't make them go away, I need a crowd of people, But I can't face them day to day". IMHO, Young and Dylan are two of the greatest song writers of the generation. |
I probably wasn't clear in what I said. I don't look at talent or art in the "American" way, where everything has to have a "best" this or that. I do prefer and enjoy the songwriting of Stephen Stills to Neil Young, but that said, Neil has written many fine songs. Graham and David also had some fine songs individually as well as together. @mwinkc I feel the same way about 4 + 20. It's a simple masterpiece. |
- 56 posts total