Not all AVR's are created equal. Anthems, for instance, are quite good musically. Their amps are very good as you know. ARC seems to work better than the other auto-eq systems. Speakers and room are way more important than the electronics.
Differences in DACs and streamers? Yes, but compared to speakers, rooms and even amps, the differences are very small. Larger than cables probably, but small. I am not sure how far up the line one has to go before the differences are audible without direct A/B listening. I have not gotten there yet. Probably above all the commodity CHI-Fi chip products. Chord? HOLO?
Personally, something to tame down the top end of those Paradigms and B&W would be first on my list. It is a matter of taste, but I am way over to the Sonas Faber, Revel balanced response speakers.
If you are more into music than movie special effects, you might consider looking at the Schiit SYN idea. Gets away from all the DSP If I did not already have the rear speakers in my guest/HT room, I would run 3.1.