Poor recordings sound gritty and raw like they were supposed to I guess. But they still are enjoyable.
I agree with you that oor recordings sound gritty and raw (the vibe I was getting the other night was bright, shrill and compressed) but I am not sure that they are supposed to sound that way. But yes, I agree with this also:
Great recordings sound excellent, so good that you get a sense of the "room" ambiance .