Upgrade From Clearaudio Satisfy CF to Tracer?


I'm looking for a direct comparison of the Satifsfy CF tonearm and the Tracer tonearm on a Performance DC table. 

I have a Clearaudio Performance DC table with Satisfy Carbon Fiber tonearm.  I'm about to upgrade my Hana SL cartridge to a Hana ML, and thinking about upgrading the tonearm to the Tracer at the same time.  I've heard good things about the Tracer, but I've not seen a comparison of the Satisfy CF to the Tracer.

Many thanks for your thoughts!
aggielaw

That was due, given their bad misfire with the magnetic arm.

 

What misfire? Never heard of anyone having issues with any Clearaudio arm.

 

@knock1 Sorry, I didn’t mean to imply the Satisfy was magnetic bearing - it’s not, and it’s a reasonable choice on the entry Clearaudio tables. I realize the way I worded the comment may give that impression.

What misfire? Never heard of anyone having issues with any Clearaudio arm.

The magnetic bearing arms were a horrible idea, and they will give problems with most flooring short of concrete slab or wall mount (maybe). Otherwise - don't play too loud, always mute before you walk around, and don't have the wrong kind of record warps. These arms solve the wrong problem - not much to gain by lowering friction beyond that of a quality rigid bearing, but the bearing itself must be stable and not so reactive to footsteps or LF feedback. 

The complaints are definitely out there. The main CMB bearing itself can cause issues too (e.g. woofer flapping) but to a lesser extent.

@mulveling There is no reason to be sorry. After rereading your post I see you did not imply that the Satisfy is magnetic bearing type and you were referring to that concept itself, which I agree was not too smart idea in itself. 

@mulveling Geez, yes the Internet is forever, but having to defend a 2 year old post is over the top!