Best digital stream player


No matter how expensive any cd player is, it is just do a best guess of what is on the cd. I don't think cd player will be completely gone in a couple years because LP is coming back. But I feel the digital stream player have big advantage over cd player and all audio company will come up with their new digital stream player in the coming years. Digital stream player either use usb or network cable to directly read music file from PC/file server and are slowly adapted by audiophiles.

Digital stream player is still new to lots of people. Which one is the best digital stream player in the market?

1)DCS Scarlatti upsampler
2)PlayBack Designs MPS-5
3)Linn Klimax DS

Or is there any other newcomers better than those three?
yxlei
Eelii08, The CD12 is a 10 year old design that was consided state of the art at the time. Linn has decided to focus on the DS instead of CD playback. Which I think more companies should do. Linn is just about 3 years ahead of most other highend companies in this regard. Digital streamers are lot harder to implement right than a simple cd player. So I think your logic that Linn is just trying to market the DS because they can't compete with other companies disc players is faulty.

Let your own ears decide.
You may be right. As stated, it was just a guess from reading and listening to what others, who are more familiar with Linn, say.

In reality, why they are only focusing in streaming is up to them. I can see an actual owner of a Linn CDP not being too happy. After spending big in a CDP -probably being told how good it was- he sees it is being discontinued cos the company, in brief, comes to say it sounds like crap compared to the DSs. Not the best to keep up the aftermarket value. But that is not my case so I don't really care. You are also right. What is important is how these things really sound and how good they are.

It is their claim that the Klimax is the best digital source out there regardless of price, that makes me doubt. I want to listen to one for sure. I don't even need it to be the absolute best (do not think there is an absolute best in audio components...). I just need it to be as good -or better- than my Esoteric to go ahead.

Listening to one is the way to go, I know. But it will only be of use if I can get to listen to one at my house, in my room and with my gear. Problem is that my dealer does not sell Linn. There is a Linn dealer at my hometown, but he does not know me. It will be hard to try to convince him to lend a 14.500 euros machine to a guy that walks from the door. I guess at the end I will be able to, but probably will need to leave a deposit of a big % of the asking price, have him come over etc, etc.

I can do that. But before going through all that trouble, I want to get as much info as possible. If feedback is positive, so chances are I will like it in relative terms to my actual source, I will proceed to that stage.
I did finally heard the klimax DS. TO ME, it was good... but not better than my Esoteric. This was a few weeks ago already, and I did post my views on a different post. However I will share my views with you here as well. Just in case they are of use to anyone. NOte as always, only my opinion to my ears, and in my sytem / room combo...

So how it was, and compared to the Esoteric X01-D2. Close in some aspects, equal in others, (very good soundstage, open and wide, nice separation and air and good dynamics). In all of the above, not better than the Esoteric, but not worse either. Very good player.

HOwever the Linn Klimax did felt short in the bass extension, Esoteric was warmer, and with deeper and nicer texture of instruments and voices. This was specially so in female voices and pianos.

Overall, a very good piece, but not better than my current CDP (actually, it felt behind to my ears and in my system.). I would define the soteric sound as more rich... sort of speak. Really don't think this is the better digital player out there... at least in my personal opinion, as Linn claims.

I decided to pass on it. It's a shame since I did want a ethernet streaming solution, but not willing to commit such an amount of money to end up probably listening most of the time to the CDP anyway.

I think I will go with a much cheaper solution for casual listening and to rip old Cds in bad condition. Eventually, other units will come to the market although this may take a while.