Team212,
I agree except for the Plant/Krauss project, which I happened to like...but
it's not a position I can logically defend. ;-) I think T-Bone is a genius, but
he's a very "big" presence in the studio from what I read. I think
his work with Sam Phillips and on his own stuff is amazing.
While we're in the genre, Buddy Miller is also good when he works with the
right engineer and mastering studio.
In case people don't know, an extant summary of each of the producers
mentioned in this thread is available through Wikipedia with hyperlinks to
each of their projects. I was surprised by a few recordings I found there.