Dear Flyingred: +++++ " I hadn't realized it would be so tough - in my experience rubber belt tables don't do good (enough for me) speed stability and leading edge transients as well as .... " +++++
Well, " speed stability " ( IMHO ) every other thibgs the same makes a huge difference and yes many BD TTs are not up to the task but there are some that are: Walker, Raven, Brinkman Simon Yorke, etc, etc, unfortunatelly some of these have very high prices.
Now, as important ( critical I say ) as is the speed stability there are other important subjects that count on the overall performance: platter material, suspension, arm board material, kind of belt used, etc, etc.
+++++ " Once you've lost some fidelity at the source you can never get it back. " +++++
This statement is of paramount importance ( specially at the analog reproduction system ) and when we really understand it we could take care in deep about in any single link of the analog chain: TT/cartridge/cartridge set-up/tonearm/cables,Phonolinepreamp, etc.
+++++ " IMO, too many people upgrade too frequently to "improve" their system when a little work with the variables would deliver the same effect " +++++
This statement it is directly related with the last one: we have to try hard on what we have trying to setting up everything on target.
+++++ " I would also challenge your assertion about cartridges - if you work on VTA/VTF/azimuty and impedance/capacitance matching then the difference between carts becomes quite subtle. " +++++
It is only on this statement that I can't agree with you because if you have a good resolution system then the differences that you could hear will not " subtle " at least was not on my experiences about. All cartridges have its own " signature sound " that is different ( not subtle ) from one to each other ( inclusive in the same manufacturer line ), maybe I never try too hard about to had what you are experienced. So I'm with Rotarius opinion on this subject.
Regards and enjoy the music.
Raul.
Well, " speed stability " ( IMHO ) every other thibgs the same makes a huge difference and yes many BD TTs are not up to the task but there are some that are: Walker, Raven, Brinkman Simon Yorke, etc, etc, unfortunatelly some of these have very high prices.
Now, as important ( critical I say ) as is the speed stability there are other important subjects that count on the overall performance: platter material, suspension, arm board material, kind of belt used, etc, etc.
+++++ " Once you've lost some fidelity at the source you can never get it back. " +++++
This statement is of paramount importance ( specially at the analog reproduction system ) and when we really understand it we could take care in deep about in any single link of the analog chain: TT/cartridge/cartridge set-up/tonearm/cables,Phonolinepreamp, etc.
+++++ " IMO, too many people upgrade too frequently to "improve" their system when a little work with the variables would deliver the same effect " +++++
This statement it is directly related with the last one: we have to try hard on what we have trying to setting up everything on target.
+++++ " I would also challenge your assertion about cartridges - if you work on VTA/VTF/azimuty and impedance/capacitance matching then the difference between carts becomes quite subtle. " +++++
It is only on this statement that I can't agree with you because if you have a good resolution system then the differences that you could hear will not " subtle " at least was not on my experiences about. All cartridges have its own " signature sound " that is different ( not subtle ) from one to each other ( inclusive in the same manufacturer line ), maybe I never try too hard about to had what you are experienced. So I'm with Rotarius opinion on this subject.
Regards and enjoy the music.
Raul.