Analog playback issues

Can you get more specific about the nature of the "garbled" sound? Distorted? Highs or lows exaggerated (which?) No volume or too much for a volume knob setting that is OK with the turner or tape player?

Did the replacement turntable have a new cartridge or did you use the old one? That could be an explanation if the cantilever or stylus were damaged.

Was this a moving magnet, moving coil or crystal cartridge? Each of these needs a different input configuration.

In what condition were your records? Vinyl can be easily damaged from rough handling, being played with a defective or damaged stylus, dirt in the grooves, or even mold growth.

This isn't the end of the list of possible explanations, so more detail would be helpful is diagnosing the problem.

Sounds like she used the same " bad " cartridge for both tables..That would make sense>>>>>>>

To be more specific in regards to the sound: you could barely hear the music, but then there would be leaps into the high register accompanied by outbursts of static(again, not sure if you have ever mistakenly plugged a cd player into the phono pre-amp of a receiver, but this was the exact effect). Like I said the cartridge is a technics sl-dd24 that is 30 or so years old which I presume to be MM. The sony table she tried briefly came with its own cartridge, but had the same result, so I rule out the possibility of it being a cartridge issue specifically. Could it be that the phono pre-amp on the receiver went bad? I thought initially that this TT has not been used in a long time, but apparently it worked fine a few months before the sound distortion started showing up. The records looked clean to me, but I am hardly an expert--I hope this expounds on the issue enough

if two entirely different TTs end up having identical malfunctions, it's pretty likely the receiver is the issue.