You are absolutely correct, Swampwalker. The Model-2 has a slot in the headshell which allows you to adjust the effective length (pivot to stylus distance) of the tonearm. The DPS and the Reference are fixed in a hole which allows the cartridge to pivot but not slide back and forth. My guess is that Frank didn't like the structural integrity of a slot milled into the hardwood headshells.
Playing with the Ellison spreadsheet will help you get the grok on all of this.
As an aside, I was pointed to a compendium of tonearm specifications (not the Vinyl Engine website). I don't have the link handy, but if ddriveman is following this thread, I'm sure he'll provide it.
Anyhow, the number of alignments chosen by the various manufacturers is astounding, and by no means limited to Baerwaald, Loefgren and Stevenson. In that document you'll find null points placed all over the map.
Many highly regarded arms (Dynavector, et. al) have specified some unknown geometery. When I get a chance, I'm going to draw some arc protractors up for some of these geometries - to the extent that I have a tonearm on hand which I can "force" into these alignments.
One of these arms is the Artisan that I carry. Way back when Ralph (Artisan) and I were evaluating the arm, we decided that we needed to have an easy means of providing the end-user with a reliable means of producing a known geometry.
Ralph and I felt that an arc-style protractor would better help the user visualize and set up their cartridge.
The visualization problem arises because the manufacturer's chosen alignment specifies an effective length that is almost 3mm short of what the 214 mm pivot to spindle distance would predict for Baerwaald. It also specifies an offset angle of about 1 degree less than what Baerwaald predicts.
To achieve a Baerwaald alignment, a cartridge of average stylus position relative to mounting bolts, with a perfectly aligned cantilever would be some 2.8mm forward of the center of the headshell slots and rotated clockwise by about 1.25 degrees from being parallel to the headshell.
All of these differences would likely confuse the user if they use their two-point Baerwaald protractor and begin the process by placing the cartridge bolts in the middle of the headshell slots and line up the front of the cartridge body so that it is parallel to the front of the headshell.
I should most definitely return to this alternate geometry exercise to understand the intent of the manufacturer. There's been no rush, since "nuts on" Baerwaald has been very, very nice.
Cheers,
Thom @ Galibier
Playing with the Ellison spreadsheet will help you get the grok on all of this.
As an aside, I was pointed to a compendium of tonearm specifications (not the Vinyl Engine website). I don't have the link handy, but if ddriveman is following this thread, I'm sure he'll provide it.
Anyhow, the number of alignments chosen by the various manufacturers is astounding, and by no means limited to Baerwaald, Loefgren and Stevenson. In that document you'll find null points placed all over the map.
Many highly regarded arms (Dynavector, et. al) have specified some unknown geometery. When I get a chance, I'm going to draw some arc protractors up for some of these geometries - to the extent that I have a tonearm on hand which I can "force" into these alignments.
One of these arms is the Artisan that I carry. Way back when Ralph (Artisan) and I were evaluating the arm, we decided that we needed to have an easy means of providing the end-user with a reliable means of producing a known geometry.
Ralph and I felt that an arc-style protractor would better help the user visualize and set up their cartridge.
The visualization problem arises because the manufacturer's chosen alignment specifies an effective length that is almost 3mm short of what the 214 mm pivot to spindle distance would predict for Baerwaald. It also specifies an offset angle of about 1 degree less than what Baerwaald predicts.
To achieve a Baerwaald alignment, a cartridge of average stylus position relative to mounting bolts, with a perfectly aligned cantilever would be some 2.8mm forward of the center of the headshell slots and rotated clockwise by about 1.25 degrees from being parallel to the headshell.
All of these differences would likely confuse the user if they use their two-point Baerwaald protractor and begin the process by placing the cartridge bolts in the middle of the headshell slots and line up the front of the cartridge body so that it is parallel to the front of the headshell.
I should most definitely return to this alternate geometry exercise to understand the intent of the manufacturer. There's been no rush, since "nuts on" Baerwaald has been very, very nice.
Cheers,
Thom @ Galibier