Any opinions on the Lyra stylus cleaning fluid?


Lyra gives a cleaning fluid with their higher priced cartridges. Some say that no fluid should ever be used because it can travel up the cantilever and create a short or deposit dirt at the least. Any opinions?
chashmal
No opinion on the Lyra fluid itself. I would expect they know what they're doing. At the same time, with the great results one can get using the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser that Doug Deacon and Paul introduced us all to, why bother? Just use the Magic Eraser.
.
I use the Lyra fluid occasionally on my Helikon and it works well. I use it very sparingly on the supplied brush and only let the bristles touch the stylus; not hard to do with a steady hand and 3.0 reading glasses.
As Rushton said, the Magic Eraser + a dry stylus brush work better than most liquid cleaners (I haven't tried the Lyra liquid, but I abandoned two other liquids and two gel type cleaners long ago).

The only thing that works better IME is a sliver of ultrafine sandpaper, as Linn supplies, but I've only needed that to rehabilitate neglected styli sent to me by friends or dealers. Regular use of the ME + brush is sufficient to prevent any buildup.

Caution: I've received correspondence from dozens (hundreds?) of audiophiles since introducing the Magic Eraser-as-stylus-cleaner four years ago. Only three of them ever experienced a problem with any stylus cleaner, and ALL THREE WERE LYRA OWNERS. Two Magic Eraser users and one Lyra liquid stylus cleaner user had their styli fall off the cantilever during cleaning. (!) From this, the prudent conclusion is that Lyra's method for affixing stylus to cantilever is (or was) less secure than most. Whatever stylus cleaner you use, proceed with care.
Any fluid is a bad idea.
It can, and, will seep into the coils/magnets and ruin your chances for a rebuild.
This is one reason I advise against buying a used cartridge.
IMHO...