Want new phono amp, what should I buy?

You've already got a Pass pre and amp, why not the Pass XP15 or XP25 phono stages?

My recommendation would be the ASR Basis Exclusive phono stage. It is a battery powered unit, that will accept up two cartridges, (with separate gain and loading for each), and will allow for balanced inputs as well.
It is extremely quiet, (with virtually no noise floor), with even very low output MC cartridges, and it is also very musical, IMHO.
I have two friends who currently use it.
(And if I could afford it, .....)

FYI, there are two versions, one is the standard "blue" board version that came out several years ago, and there is the newer "gold" board version that is slightly better, (and of course more expensive). The older version typically runs around $3-4K used, and the newer version around $5-6K.

I've been very happy with Herron vtph-2 mm/mc phono preamp. A search on audiogon will show it has a cult following.

Don't sell the Artisan short, esp. w a ZYX cart. In a head to head comparison on a very high resolution analog rig (Teres 365, Triplanar, ZYX Universe, Doshi-Lectron, B&W 802Ds), the Artisan was substantially better than a Rhea Signature w NOS tubes. The phono stages we listened to that day, in pretty much unanimous agreement, were, in overall descending order of SQ, were Doshi-Alaap > Manley Steelhead = Artisan >> Rhea Signature. YMMV, but I'd try it at home before parting w long green on the Rhea. Never heard the others that have been mentioned.

My friend has that table and arm and uses a Pass phono and pre. I use the Basis Exclusive mentioned above. But all systems are different and we all hear differently so it would be hard to say which would sound best to you. I would also try to hear the Audia phono stage.