Agree w Jrfech
I never saw mine get as dirty as the picand Stringreen
If the stylus guard was on, and the packing secure the guy that put it in the box broke it. ...or you are dealing with a dishonest guy. There is no way to break a stylus with the guard intact.Something is not right. I'd give the seller the opportunity to make it right, but I don't think that there is any way that this is shipping damage.