That last paragraph from Ptmconsulting rang a bell inside my head. When I was dialing in anti-skate with a gimballed arm(not unipivot), and I tried to equalize the sound in both channels, I lost my excitement for listening to music. I then put the anti-skate back where it was(these were extremely tiny adjustments.). This situation was confirmed with some very obscure research I found on the internet. It makes sense, though. Should you be using anti-skate to adjust for tiny differences in turntable levelling, acoustics, slight differences in driver makeup, etc.? I believe in listening enough to determine just what anti-skate actually does(when you just slightly change it, both in increasing and decreasing it). Now, of course, you have to have it very close to it's optimum setting, before you do this.
Note: I am not saying that Ctlphd's problem is anti-skate.