Elizabeth, best I can make out from your post, that scenario will hum. The problem is that the stock arm cable uses the minus output of the cartridge as a shield, so if that is used on pin 3 of the XLR you will have a substantial hum.
Its unfortunate that the arm does not have a 5-pin connector or else this would be really easy. But it does have the little circuit board, so it is possible.a
Its unfortunate that the arm does not have a 5-pin connector or else this would be really easy. But it does have the little circuit board, so it is possible.a