New VPI Classic I vs. good used VPI HW-19 MkIV.

In that case, I would take the HW19 MK4 without hesitation. The Graham is a very very good arm and IMO a much better arm than what is on the Classic. The Graham is also a good complement to the HW19's fullness of tone. I lived with a MK4 for a few years and found it to be excellent, not much behind my current TNT6. Good luck.

I agree with the frogmeister. The tables are pretty close, relatively speaking, but the Graham arm is a big step up from the VPI.

In a private email from Harry W once, he told me the Classic can be gotten minus the JMW Arm. And that it can be fitted with other Arms. What the price is minus Arm, I have no idea, but this could be an option for those who maybe have an Arm on hand, or another arm in mind.