I would go with new. I have had little luck with the reliability of used, older turntables.
In one of my systems, I have an Audio Technica AT-120LP available for $250 with free shipping from a number of eBay sellers. It has a built-in preamp, a decent sounding cartridge, and is built like a tank. She will have this turntable through high school and possibly college. It is a manual turntable, but I don't think that is an issue to a generation of kids that would be accustomed to using iMacs and iPods and iPhones and iEtc.
I am a big believer in starting kids out early with decent equipment that produces decent sound. It is how an appreciation for good sound can start.
Rich
In one of my systems, I have an Audio Technica AT-120LP available for $250 with free shipping from a number of eBay sellers. It has a built-in preamp, a decent sounding cartridge, and is built like a tank. She will have this turntable through high school and possibly college. It is a manual turntable, but I don't think that is an issue to a generation of kids that would be accustomed to using iMacs and iPods and iPhones and iEtc.
I am a big believer in starting kids out early with decent equipment that produces decent sound. It is how an appreciation for good sound can start.
Rich