Well, who knew?
Here's a modern (2012) all-analog recording, mastering, and limited edition pressing of the
Bach Suites performed by Rocco Filippini on 180g vinyl at less than half the price of the Speakers Corner Starker.
I have no direct experience with this artist or recording, but it certainly looks promising.
What prompted me to search for alternatives is that I just heard the 4th Suite by
Luigi Piovana, and it's fabulous. I couldn't turn the radio off. It's a digital recording available (AFAIK) only on CD, but to this vinylphile it sounded *really* good and the performance is quite compelling, as in, it compels you to sit in the sweet spot and listen to the whole thing.